Evaluating nuclear medicine imaging devices using fuzzy. Pdf in this paper, an alternative version of the fuzzy promethee preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluations method is. As an approach for multiple criteria decision making mcdm, it. Fuzzy outranking methods including fuzzy promethee. For supplier evaluation process through fuzzy promethee. The proposed method is compared with vikor and other mcdm methods. Having used the fuzzy analytic hierarchy processahp and promethee methods in combination with gis, the optimal zones were located. Selection of stocks using constrained fuzzy ahp and. This paper applies fuzzy promethee to rank a set of suppliers. Outranking methods are a family of techniques concerned with ranking the preference for alternatives based on the criteria values that describe them. Integrating fuzzy analytic hierarchy process with promethee method for total quality management consultant selection golam kabira and razia sultana sumib aschool of engineering, university of british columbia ubc, 3333 university way, kelowna. Fuzzy promethee analysis of leukemia treatment techniques wcrj.
Differently from other studies, preference functions used in promethee method are handled in terms of fuzzy distances between alternatives with respect to each criterion. Chapter xxxii fuzzy outranking methods including fuzzy promethee. Fuzzy outranking methods including fuzzy promethee is constrained around the family of outranking methods available. Pdf an alternative approach based on fuzzy promethee. Table 2v shows the values for different cars, with the best value for each criterion in bold. Therapy is very important in order to increase the chances of survival from the dis. Integrating fuzzy analytic hierarchy process with promethee. Evaluation and ranking of suppliers with fuzzy dea and. Multicriteria evaluation of urban regeneration processes. Fuzzy promethee gdss for technical requirements ranking in. Conclusion using fuzzy promethee as a multicriteria analysis technique, we were able to achieve good decision results by incorporating fuzzy input data. Bottani and rizzi 4 applied fuzzy topsis for selecting the best suppliers.
Multi criteria supplier selection using fuzzy promethee. Critical path definition using multicriteria decision making. Preference ranking organization method of enrichment. In this paper, the classical topsis algorithms for crisp, as well as interval data are described. This article contains a short introduction to the multicriteria decision aid system promethee. An mpolar fuzzy promethee approach for ahpassisted.
Pdf promethee and fuzzy promethee multicriteria methods for. The preference ranking organization method for enrichment of evaluations and its descriptive complement geometrical analysis for interactive aid are better known as the promethee and gaia methods. In third section, the real case application of the study and results are given. Relatedly, the extended version of the promethee method for decisionmaking in the fuzzy environment is introduced by. Abstractfuzzy preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation f promethee was applied for choosing among potential logistics center locations. Fuzzy promethee deals with problems characterized by uncertainty and is based on a comparison of the alternatives with regard to their criteria. Evaluation fuzzy promethee method to evaluate four. Mining method selection by integrated ahp and promethee. Relatedly, the extended version of the promethee method for decisionmaking in the fuzzy environment is introduced by goumas and lygerou 39. Pdf integrating fuzzy analytic hierarchy process with. Also, alpay and yavuz 2009 have suggested a combination of ahp and fuzzy logic methods for underground mining method selection. The preference ranking order method for enrichment evaluation promethee is a multicriteria decision making mcdm. Decision making, fuzzypromethee, similarity measure, fuzzy distance.
The fuzzy promethee method was applied on nuclear medicine imaging devices. Evaluating cancer treatment alternatives using fuzzy promethee method dilber uzun ozsahina,b, berna uzun a, musa sani musa, abdulkader helwana, chidi nwekwo wilson, fatih veysel nurcin a, niyazi senturk, ilker ozsahina anear east university, near east boulevard, zip. The promethee method has some strength in the comparison with existing methods thanks to its simplicity and capacity to approximate the way that human mind expresses and synthesizes preferences when facing multiple. Material selection is a complex problem in the design and development of products for diverse engineering applications. Due to the varying importance of the used criteria, we develop fuzzy ahp software based on extent analysis method to assign the. The aim of this paper is to present the fuzzy preference. Using fuzzy preference method for group package tour based on. Numerical example the fuzzy promethee has been applied to a suppliers ranking problem. Fuzzy promethee preference ranking organization method for enrichment of evaluations a multicriteria decisionmaking process was used to evaluate the treatments on factors that include side effects, overall survival rate, cost of treatment and treatment time. The promethee method is a multicriteria decision aid system that permits the building of an outranking between different alternatives. Pdf promethee and fuzzy promethee multicriteria methods. The method is improved in the present work by integrating with analytic hierarchy process ahp and the fuzzy logic. Preference ranking organization method of enrichment evaluation promethee by 1,s.
This study explores group package tour gpt itineraries based on comparative risk methodology using the fuzzy preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation promethee. The following section shows the application of promethee by a numerical example. The proposed methodology combines two classical methods to find the most appropriate design for the new product, through a reduced number of alternatives product variants and experiments for the selection process. Abstractfuzzy preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation fpromethee was applied for choosing among potential logistics center locations. Lee 1 proposed to select suppliers under a fuzzy approach. A fuzzy promethee approach for breast cancer treatment. The paper illustrates the development of an evaluation model for supporting the decisionmaking process related to an urban regeneration intervention. Integrating fuzzy analytic hierarchy process with promethee method for total quality management consultant selection.
Application of ahp, fuzzy ahp and promethee method in solving. The method combines the concept of fuzzy sets to represent uncertain information with the promethee, a subgroup of multicriteria decisionmaking mcdm methods. Applied fmcdm methods fuzzy ahpfuzzy promethee are explained and the eservice quality dimensions and proposed evaluation model are described. Critical path definition using multicriteria decision. Section 4 applies the combined approach to produce an efficient solution to the stock selection problem. A prometheebased method is applied by govindan et al.
Therapy is very important in order to increase the chances of survival from the disease. Fuzzy failure mode and effects analysis in a pharmaceutical. Based on mathematics and sociology, the promethee and gaia method was developed at the beginning of the 1980s and has been extensively studied and. The methodology to support multicriteria decision promethee is compared with the fuzzypromethee method, which is associated with the. Chapter xxxii fuzzy outranking methods including fuzzy. New application of promethee for material selection problem. Leukemia is an abnormal division of cells that results in the formation of abnor mal whiteblood cells. Using hybrid fuzzy promethee ii and fuzzy binary goal. An example demonstrates the usability and validity of the proposed method.
This paper proposes the use of the preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation promethee method under fuzzy environments in order to determine the critical path of a network, considering not only time but also cost, quality, and safety criteria. The fuzzy ahp method is used to determine the weights of the criteria whereas the promethee ii method is used to prioritise the alternatives based on the weights obtained from the fuzzy ahp. The main goal of this paper was to introduce the methodology for product design selection. Associate professor,buali sina university of hamedan,iran 2. This paper presents a fuzzy promethee preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation method based on trapezoidal fuzzy interval numbers that can be applied to the selection of. This paper presents a hybrid multicriteria fuzzy method for the selection of the carrier among a number of preselected logistics service providers. Software selection in manufacturing industries using a fuzzy. The method was developed and applied to the case of powerone inc. Finally, the last section clarifies the conclusion and future suggestions.
Topsis method, many other extensions have been proposed, providing support for interval or fuzzy criteria, interval or fuzzy weights to modeled imprecision, uncertainty, lack of information or vagueness. The philosophy of outranking methods origi nates from the pioneering work of bernard roy roy, 1968. Fuzzy failure mode and effects analysis in a pharmaceutical production process with fuzzy promethee method. This paper presents a hybrid multicriteriafuzzy method for the selection of the carrier among a number of preselected logistics service providers.
Then, fuzzy topsis is used for ranking the alternatives again and the results of the two methods are compared using the spearman method. Application of ahp, fuzzy ahp and promethee method in. It combines the concepts of fuzzy sets to represent the uncertain information in intrinsic risks with promethee, a subgroup of multicriteria decision making. Preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation. The aim of the research in this paper is to obtain taindexes of the bp countries by using multicriteria analysis. Especially the outranking method promethee brings together flexibility and simplicity for the user and is therefore chosen for the enhancement towards the evaluation of fuzzy data on preferences. The proposed method can handle the uncertainty in the decision making. The promethee method is preferred in ranking and selecting alternatives due to its robustness in comparing the performances of alternatives and considers it in the composite ranking. Abstract this paper provides a fuzzy preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation promethee in a group decision support system gdss approach to ranking the technical requirements for the house of quality hoq process in multicriteria product design. The fuzzypromethee method based on trapezoidal fuzzy numbers. The promethee is an outranking approach of mcda methods introduced by. In particular, the study proposes an original multimethodological approach, which combines swot analysis, stakeholders analysis and promethee method for the evaluation of alternative renewal strategies of an urban area in northern italy. Then, using the fuzzy binary goal programming, the most important risks are selected and finally ranked via the fuzzy. Software selection in manufacturing industries using a.
Environmental planning for wind power plant site selection. Just as in other mcdm methods, there is a fuzzy extension of the promethee method when dealing with uncertain and subjective data. Failure mode and effects analysis fmea is a quality improvement technique that defines potential errors and ranks them according to their degree of. Evaluating cancer treatment alternatives using fuzzy. Integrating fuzzy analytic hierarchy process with promethee method for total quality management consultant selection golam kabira and razia sultana sumib aschool of engineering, university of british columbia ubc, 3333 university way, kelowna v1v1v7, british columbia, canada.
A multilevel hybrid approach for selection of agile. Multicriteria decision making with intuitionistic fuzzy. Abstractthis study proposes the fuzzypromethee method for the textbook selection. In the first stage, the multicriteria decisionmaking method, promethee was used for. Applied fmcdm methods fuzzy ahp fuzzy promethee are explained and the eservice quality dimensions and proposed evaluation model are described. Multicriteria decision making mcdm comprises of methods such as.
Abstractthis paper applies fuzzy promethee outranking multicriteria decision analysis method to solve supplier ranking problem. Using fuzzy preference method for group package tour based. The triangular fuzzy number and ranking method are integrated into. Development of a hybrid method based on fuzzy promethee and anp in the framework of swot analysis for strategic decisions dr. Selection of stocks using constrained fuzzy ahp and promethee. The triangular fuzzy concept is applied in order to find the weights of the criteria on the basis of which the suppliers are ranked. Goumas and lygerou employed fuzzy promethee method to evaluate the alternatives of energy absorption. Additive manufacturing is a technology of making a three dimesional solid object of any shape from a digital model. In this paper, an alternative version of the fuzzy promethee preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluations method is proposed. Promethee and fuzzy promethee are multicriteria decisionmaking techniques which are explained in section 3. Feb 14, 2019 for the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration. A promethee based method is applied by govindan et al. Mining method selection by integrated ahp and promethee method.
An alternative approach based on fuzzy promethee method. Abstract in a portfolio selection problem, the first step is to choose suitable stocks at the right time. The proposed method is tested by using correlation coefficient. In this paper, a total of five criteria have been considered to rank the suppliers. Promethee preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluations for comparing, ranking and selecting the most suitable cloud computing to accommodate and access big data. Application of ahp, fuzzy ahp and promethee method in solving additive manufacturing process selection problem. Fuzzy logic is introduced to handle the imprecision of the human decision making process. In this paper, the promethee method is used, as well as a mathematical tool in order to obtain ta indexes. The purpose of this paper is to develop a method to select the best alternative in a multi. In this paper, we used fuzzy promethee technique to evaluate the cancer treatment alternatives corresponding to their parameters.
The objective of this research is to analyze the most common therapeutic techniques for leukemia, such as radiotherapy, targeted drug treatment, immunotherapy, genetherapy, stemcell. In the present study, one of the decision making techniques, fuzzy promethee technique, was employed to compare suppliers. For supplier evaluation process through fuzzy promethee method. Leukemia is an abnormal division of cells that results in the formation of abnormal whiteblood cells. Selection of stocks using constrained fuzzy ahp and promethee li chen, heping pan. Logistics freight center locations decision by using fuzzy. This paper presents a fuzzy promethee preference ranking organization method for enrichment evaluation method based on trapezoidal fuzzy interval numbers that can be applied to the selection of materials for an automotive instrument panel. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. The preference ranking organization method for enrichment of evaluations promethee is an outranking family of multicriteria decision. For the love of physics walter lewin may 16, 2011 duration. Using fuzzy promethee to select countries for developmental aid. Let us illustrate the promethee method with the problem of choosing a car. Selection of logistic service provider using fuzzy. Computing the differences in the alternatives, contribution is based on the weight and preference function of each criterion.
Fuzzy promethee analysis of leukemia treatment techniques. The method is illustrated, validated, and compared against three different fuzzy mcdm methods fuzzy vikor, fuzzy topsis, and fuzzy electre in terms of its. Request pdf multi criteria supplier selection using fuzzy promethee method the fundamental objective of supply chain management scm is to integrate various suppliers to satisfy market demand. Promethee method implementation with multicriteria decisions 197, 1 xa ipax ta i.
Our enhancement of the promethee with intuitionistic fuzzy set, named ifpromethee, takes not only intuitionistic fuzzy preferences, but also intuitionistic fuzzy weights into account. Two practical examples are carried out to illustrate the applicability and efficiency of our proposed method in solving multicriteria decision making problems. A fuzzy logic based promethee method for material selection. Selection problem of cloud solution for big data accessing. The triangular fuzzy number and ranking method are integrated into the promethee ii method.
593 1137 862 803 248 36 1454 392 1199 82 350 166 1424 365 124 830 1519 302 386 707 529 253 1076 1418 741 930 498 1148 1520 618 438 1159 197 217 1489 1240 724 775 1194 505 997 42 1116 591 43 544 1096